Comparison of outcomes for Draf IIB vs Draf III in endoscopic frontal sinus surgery: a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis
Hirayama, Y Shahid, M S Finney, H A Muzaffar, J Haque, M S Accorona, R Iftikhar, H
Hirayama, Y
Shahid, M S
Finney, H A
Muzaffar, J
Haque, M S
Accorona, R
Iftikhar, H
Affiliation
University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust; Aga Khan University; Aga Khan University Hospital; University of Birmingham; ASST Grande Ospedale Metropolitano Niguarda; Northampton General Hospital NHS Trust
Other Contributors
Publication date
2025-06-01
Collections
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Abstract
Background: Understanding the factors associated with increased rates of restenosis following Draf procedures is crucial for developing targeted strategies to mitigate complications such as mucocele formation, reduce the need for revision surgeries, and improve long-term patient outcomes.
Methodology: A systematic search was conducted using Embase, Medline, CINAHL, AMED, PubMed, and the Cochrane Database on January 17th, 2024. Research articles published in English language were included. Abstracts were independently screened by two reviewers, and data were extracted and assessed for quality in adherence to PRISMA guidelines. Meta- and sub-group analyses were conducted using the REML model and random-effects model to address high heterogenity and I2 values.
Results: A total of 96 studies met the inclusion criteria. For the Draf IIB subgroup (15 studies, 239 sinuses), the restenosis rate was 7%, compared to 20% in the Draf III subgroup (40 studies, 1,910 sinuses). Revision surgery rates were 5% for Draf IIB versus 12% for Draf III. Adjuvant interventions, such as steroid-impregnated stents, were associated with improved outcomes, showing an ostium patency OR of 2.20.
Conclusion: Draf IIB had superior outcomes compared to Draf III with respect to restenosis and revision surgery. The use of steroid-impregnated stents appears effective in reducing restenosis rates.
Citation
Hirayama Y, Shahid MS, Finney HA, Muzaffar J, Haque MS, Accorona R, Iftikhar H. Comparison of outcomes for Draf IIB vs Draf III in endoscopic frontal sinus surgery: a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis. Rhinology. 2025 Jun 1;63(3):258-285. doi: 10.4193/Rhin24.507.
Type
Article