A cost consequence analysis of seven diagnostic strategies for ovarian cancer: a model-based economic evaluation

Objective: To assess the costs and consequences of seven diagnostic strategies for ovarian cancer in pre- and post-menopausal women with symptoms in secondary care. Design: Economic evaluation alongside a prospective single-arm diagnostic accuracy study. Setting: NHS secondary care outpatients (2-week referrals, clinics, GP referrals, cross-specialty referrals) and inpatients (emergency presentations to secondary care). Sample: Two cohorts of 857 pre-menopausal and 1242 post-menopausal women newly presenting to secondary care with symptoms of suspected ovarian cancer. Methods: A model-based cost-consequence analysis (CCA) was conducted using a decision tree simulating patient pathways over 12 months. Diagnostic accuracy data were sourced from the ROCkeTS study and supplemented by literature. Main outcome measures: Cancer deaths, correct diagnosis proportion, and diagnostic yield. Results: No diagnostic strategy was optimal across all outcomes. Across both cohorts, the Risk of Malignancy Index (RMI) 200 was least expensive but had poor cancer death and diagnostic yield outcomes. The ADNEX 3% strategy had the highest diagnostic yield and lowest cancer mortality but was the most expensive. For pre-menopausal women, the IOTA ADNEX 10% strategy outperformed ORADS, ROMA, and CA125 in cost and outcomes. For post-menopausal women, the high cancer prevalence required a trade-off. In sensitivity analysis, a two-step IOTA ADNEX 10% strategy outperformed ORADS, ROMA, and CA125 across all three outcomes, making the strategy a more balanced choice in both cohorts. Conclusion: At 12 months, no single diagnostic strategy was superior. Early diagnosis requires balancing cancer mortality, diagnostic yield, and cost. The IOTA ADNEX two-step strategy at a 10% threshold provided the best trade-off across these factors and is recommended for practice.

Citation

Perry SJ, Griffin D, Williams EV, Roberts TE, Kwong FL, Williams S, Deeks J, Scandrett K, Agarwal R, Sundar SS, Monahan M. A Cost Consequence Analysis of Seven Diagnostic Strategies for Ovarian Cancer: A Model-Based Economic Evaluation. BJOG. 2025 Nov 5. doi: 10.1111/1471-0528.70074. Epub ahead of print.

Type

Article