Can ultrasound strain elastography (USE) improve management of suspicious thyroid nodules measuring <10 mm? A systematic review
Klarich, S White, H
Klarich, S
White, H
Citations
Altmetric:
Affiliation
Walsall Healthcare NHS Trust; Birmingham City University
Other Contributors
Publication date
2023-05-04
Subject
Collections
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Abstract
Introduction: Current UK guidelines state that suspicious thyroid nodules <10 mm do not require FNA. These are often followed up with serial ultrasound scans. Ultrasound Strain Elastography (USE) could provide a more accurate alternative and preclude the need for follow-up. Can USE identify nodules at greater risk of malignancy and streamline patient management?
Methods: Systematic review methodology used. Inclusion criteria are: - Population: patients with suspicious thyroid nodules <10 mm.- Intervention: USE.- Comparator: Ultrasound features of nodules.- Outcome measure: FNA or surgical removal of nodules. Searches performed on 6 commercial databases, along with grey literature anddissertation databases. The QUADAS-2 diagnostic study checklist used for quality assessment.
Results: 8 studies included and a narrative analysis performed due to heterogeneity of results. The mean USE sensitivity is 74.3%, mean specificity 80.5%. Mean overall ultrasound sensitivity is 80.4%, specificity 71.0%. Results suggest that USE is not superior to ultrasound for detecting malignancy. Some study limitations, particularly the heterogeneity of reporting the ultrasound features preclude meaningful conclusion from being drawn.
Conclusion: USE is more accurate at identifying benign nodules than ultrasound. Nodules appearing benign on USE could be excluded from serial ultrasound follow-up. No significant difference was found between USE and ultrasound at identifying malignant nodules.
Implications for practice: As FNA is not recommended for suspicious thyroid nodules <10 mm, these are often followed up with multiple scans and clinician reviews. This increases pressure on healthcare systems and uncertainty for the patient. This review shows that USE is more accurate at identifying benign nodules than ultrasound alone, meaning that these nodules could potentially be excluded from serial follow up. This would streamline patient management, freeing-up vital resources in ENT and ultrasound departments.
Citation
Klarich, S., & White, H. (2023). Can ultrasound strain elastography (USE) improve management of suspicious thyroid nodules measuring <10 mm? A systematic review. Radiography (London, England : 1995), 29(3), 661–667.
Type
Article