The effect of smoking on union rates following corrective osteotomies around the knee : a systematic review and meta-analysis

Abstract

Background: Distal femur osteotomies (DFO) and high tibial osteotomies (HTO), are well-established treatment options for joint preservation in active patients with uni-compartmental osteoarthritis. Optimal outcomes are contingent on adequate preoperative evaluation of patient-specific factors. This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to explore the difference in union rates between smokers and non-smokers following corrective osteotomies around the knee.

Methods: A systematic search of the MEDLINE and EMBASE databases was performed in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines to identify studies reporting smoking status in adults who developed delayed and/or non-union following HTO or DFO. Studies were pooled using a random effect model [Review Manager (RevMan) software, V.5.4] and heterogeneity was estimated using I2.

Results: Data for meta-analysis was available for 1,406 osteotomies from 10 studies, performed in patients with mean age ranging from 38-54 years, and 65% were male. The union rate among non-smokers was 97.3% (1100/1131) compared with 89.5% (246/275) among smokers; OR 4.59 [95% CI 1.99 to 10.62], p-value < 0.001. Subgroup analysis revealed that the risk of non-union in smokers after opening wedge osteotomy was almost double (OR 4.8) that of closing wedge osteotomies (OR 2.9).

Conclusion: Smoking increases the risk of non-union during elective knee osteotomy surgery. Our findings also suggest that smokers have a better chance of achieving union with closing wedge osteotomy compared to open wedge osteotomy.