Research (Articles)
Recent Submissions
-
Exploring barriers and facilitators to self-management for patients with persistent musculoskeletal conditions following NHS-led hydrotherapy : a service evaluationIntroduction: Persistent musculoskeletal (MSK) disorders are one of the leading reasons for years lived with disability within the UK. Guidelines encourage integrating self-management support. Hydrotherapy supports patients with persistent MSK conditions; however, self-management following NHS-led hydrotherapy has been inconsistent. Aim: To identify outcomes of hydrotherapy alongside the barriers, facilitators, and contributory factors affecting self-management in the local persistent MSK pain population. Methods: Between April 2023 and May 2023, a service evaluation was undertaken exploring factors affecting self-management in the local persistent MSK pain population following NHS-led hydrotherapy. Demographics, clinical factors, functional status (MSK-HQ) and patient-reported experiences, including barriers and facilitators to self-management, were recorded. Data was analysed using descriptive statistics alongside exploration of themes. Results: Ninety patients completed hydrotherapy. White British (n = 24) and Indian British (n = 23) were the most common groups to attend. Multiple joint (n = 27) and spinal conditions (n = 26) were the most common MSK conditions. Mean pre- and post-MSK-HQ scores were 20.8 and 26.1, respectively. Among the contactable patients (n = 69), 49 patients did not maintain independent water-based self-management reporting barriers such as ongoing support, access and financial concerns. Patients supported the establishment of a support group (n = 56) to help maintain water-based exercises. Conclusions: The local persistent MSK pain population lacks self-efficacy for independent water-based self-management. A supportive and collaborative approach is proposed to address this via a patient-led hydrotherapy support group.
-
Optimising musculoskeletal patient flow through digital triage and supported self-management : a service evaluation set within community musculoskeletal careIntroduction: Musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions are one of the leading causes of years of living with disability in the UK, resulting in pressure on the health system and the UK economy. In response to the increasing levels of patients accessing NHS care with MSK conditions across Sandwell and West Birmingham (SWB), a digital triage and self-management tool was implemented in 2023. Aims: To optimise safety, efficiency, and choice within the community MSK service from the first contact through to specialist MSK care through digital triage and supported self-management. Methods: SWB's community MSK service implemented two digital tools in January 2023. Objectives included 1. Increase safety, through providing 24/7 access to rapid digital MSK triage; 2. Optimise workforce by releasing clinicians back to face-to-face care, increasing clinical capacity, 3. Increase patient choice by offering digitally supported self-management to appropriate low risk patients. Results: 4804 patients self-referred to the MSK service through the digital triage tool within the first 12 months. 378 of these patients were offered, accepted, and accessed self-management support using the digital self-management app. These innovations led to the release of 1240 clinical hours for face-to-face care, an average 8-week reduction in waiting times and high patient satisfaction (80% good/very good). Conclusion: Evaluation over the first 12 month showed that the digital innovations were safe, led to enhanced access to and choice of care pathways, optimised use of clinical staff, and received positive patient feedback. Research is needed in this newly emerging area of practice to support further adoption across the healthcare system.
-
Clinical characteristics and variation in musculoskeletal complexity of different ethnic populations accessing Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospital's MSK Service : a service evaluationIntroduction: Health inequality is a global public health challenge, limited by insufficient high-quality data and analysis. Musculoskeletal (MSK) pain disorders are more prevalent among ethnic minority groups disproportionately affected by socioeconomic disparities and poor health outcomes. Ethnicity data collection enables NHS organisations and policymakers to understand specific healthcare needs and ensure equitable access and care provision. Objective: To understand the baseline clinical characteristics across ethnic population groups accessing MSK care at Sandwell and West Birmingham (SWB) NHS Trust. Methods: Retrospective analysis of routine data collected using patient self-report surveys (August 2020-February 2023). Core metrics included demographics, pain characteristics, and Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) including the Musculoskeletal Health Questionnaire (MSK-HQ) and Numeric Pain Rating Scale (NPRS). Descriptive statistics and statistical tests were undertaken, with means, percentage values and variation by ethnic groups across baseline MSK-HQ and pain scores reported. Results: Survey data were provided by 13,248 patients, with 7295 (55.06%) stating their ethnicity. Statistical differences were found between baseline MSK-HQ and NPRS scores between ethnic groups. The mean MSK-HQ score was 24.1 overall, lowest in the Asian group (22.3) and highest in the Mixed group (24.8). Mean baseline pain intensity was (7.8), highest in the Asian group (8.3). One or more comorbidities were present in 46% of patients, with the highest percentage in the White and Black groups sequentially. Conclusion: Baseline health inequalities exist among ethnic groups accessing the SWB MSK service. Disparities may be associated with patient or system barriers and require further exploration.
-
Quality indicators for the primary and community care of musculoskeletal conditions : a systematic reviewObjectives: To identify, appraise, and synthesize common themes from quality indicator (QI) sets designed for the assessment, management, and rehabilitation of musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions in primary and community care contexts. Data sources: A systematic search was performed on six databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, AMED, Web of Sciences Core Collection, The Cochrane Library, and The Health Management Information Consortium), public repositories, and the websites of organizations involved in the reporting of MSK QIs. Study selection: Potential QI sources were screened for relevance using an a priori criteria. After the screening of 1493 titles, abstracts, 71 articles were reviewed independently by two authors, of which 25 met our criteria and were therefore included within the review. Data extraction: The development of the QI sets was appraised using the AIRE instrument. Key characteristics of QI sets were extracted and tabulated. Nine out of 25 QI sets had "high" developmental methodology quality. A total of 410 QIs were identified from 25 QI sets. Data synthesis: A narrative synthesis was undertaken to identify common themes among QIs. Themes were mapped against improvement drivers mentioned in recent British primary/community MSK care policy directives. Finally, "Draft Indicators" were synthesized from common themes identified. Eleven overarching themes were synthesized: policy and governance; optimizing access and provision of care; staffing and spending; optimizing assessment and diagnosis; optimizing patient education and self-management; pharmacology and injection guideline adherence; optimizing personalized care; optimizing imaging, investigations, and referral; public health management relevant to MSK conditions; optimizing patient experience; and optimizing patient outcomes. Conclusions: This review has identified common themes among QIs that focus on optimizing assessment, investigations, and treatment decisions for the primary/community care of MSK conditions. This work represents a valuable resource to commissioners, service managers, and clinicians internationally who resource, monitor, manage, assess, and rehabilitate individuals with MSK conditions.
-
Physical prognostic factors predicting outcome following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: A systematic review and narrative synthesis.Background: Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries are common. Many patients undergo ACL reconstruction (ACLR), with rehabilitation key to successful outcome. Understanding physical prognostic factors is integral to clinical decision-making, but factors predicting outcome are inadequately defined. The objective was to establish physical prognostic factors predicting outcome following ACLR. Methods: A systematic review following a published protocol (CRD42019127732) searched MEDLINE, CINAHL, EMBASE, key journals and grey literature to November 28, 2020. Prospective cohort studies, participants ≥16 years of age who had undergone ACLR were included, with multi-ligament and/or ACL repair surgery, and studies not published in English excluded. Two independent reviewers conducted searches, extracted data, assessed risk of bias (QUIPS) and overall quality of evidence (GRADE). Meta-analysis was not possible, therefore narrative synthesis was performed. Results: 13 studies (16 articles) were included (1 low, 12 high risk of bias). Low-level evidence supports postoperative degenerative changes and poor lower-limb strength predicting poorer outcome long term (KOOS). Very low-level evidence supports greater postoperative quadriceps strength predicting improved functional performance medium term; with lower body mass index predicting improvement of multiple outcome measures. Conclusion: Limited evidence of low or very low-level indicates multiple prognostic factors predicting outcome following ACLR. A high-quality prognostic study is required.
-
Goal setting in physiotherapy-led adult musculoskeletal care : a scoping reviewIntroduction: Goal setting is a key part of rehabilitation across various fields of physiotherapy. It is less clear what evidence exists to underpin its effectiveness and to practically guide its use within musculoskeletal physiotherapy. Objectives: This scoping review provides an overview of current research regarding goal setting in adult physiotherapy-led musculoskeletal care with three aims: 1) to identify and analyse any gaps in the literature, 2) to identify relevant features of goal setting theory and 3) to make recommendations for future research. The principal research question was what does the literature tell us about the role of goal setting for adults over the age of 18 with musculoskeletal pain accessing outpatient physiotherapy services? Inclusion criteria: The population, concept and context framework was used to define the inclusion criteria. Key definitions were adults over the age of 18 with musculoskeletal conditions, goal setting, and physiotherapy-led interventions. Methods: This scoping review followed the guidance set out by the Joanna Briggs Institute Manual for Evidence Synthesis. Allied and Complementary Medicine Database, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature Plus with Full Text, MEDLINE, American Psychological Association PsycInfo and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Protocols and Trials were searched using pre-defined search criteria. Data were extracted from screened full-text articles and presented in basic statistical and narrative form. Results: 41 articles were included in the review. Several broad themes and research methods were identified. The nature of the studies suggested that the clinical application of goal setting is complex and the depth of understanding is limited. Most studies suggested that goal setting is feasible and has a positive impact on outcomes. A common finding was a lack of clear definitions regarding goal setting terminology and approaches. Study samples were generally defined by biomedical categories, suggesting a pathoanatomical approach to researching a cognitive construct. Theoretical underpinning was lacking in many studies. No frameworks guiding goal setting in physiotherapy-led musculoskeletal rehabilitation have been identified. Conclusions: Goal setting is a popular tool within musculoskeletal outpatient physiotherapy. Further research is required to clarify its efficacy and provide guidance on its role and application in clinical practice.
-
Physical harms associated with suprascapular nerve block interventions in the non-surgical management of acute and chronic shoulder pain : a systematic reviewThe utility of the suprascapular nerve block (SSNB) in the non-surgical management of shoulder pain continues to be explored, whilst its associated physical harms have not. This systematic review aims to report the physical harms associated with the SSNB in the non-surgical management of shoulder pain. Methods: A search was undertaken of AMED, CINAHL, Cochrane Library, EMBASE, Medline, Pubmed, and Scopus databases. Studies were included if they reported the presence or absence of harm following a SSNB intervention (injection, pulsed radiofrequency, ablation) in the non-surgical management of acute or chronic shoulder pain. Excluded studies were those which utilised SSNB for peri, intra, or post-surgical intervention. The McMaster tool for assessing quality of harms assessment and reporting was utilised. Results: A total of 111 studies were included in this review of which 168 episodes of harm were reported across 4142 participants. Harm severity ranged from pneumothorax (n = 5) to local pain and bruising (n = 50). The quality of harms assessment and reporting across all studies was poor. Discussion: Despite heterogeneity in SSNB intervention, and low-quality evidence, SSNB carries a low risk of physical harm. Further work is needed in addressing the poor quality of harms assessment and reporting in SSNB studies.
-
Age-related changes in reticulospinal contributions to anticipatory postural adjustments between back extensors and abdominal musclesAnticipatory postural adjustments (APAs) give feedforward postural control of the trunk, but they are delayed with ageing, affecting balance and mobility in older individuals. The reticulospinal tract contributes to postural control of the trunk; however, the extent to which age-related changes affect the reticulospinal contributions to APAs of the trunk remains unknown in humans. Here, we tested the hypothesis that a startling acoustic sound, which activates the reticulospinal tract, improves delayed APAs in older individuals. Twenty-two old (75 ± 6 years) and 20 healthy young adults (21 ± 4 years) performed a self-initiated fast bilateral shoulder flexion or shoulder extension task in response to visual, visual and auditory (80 dB), or visual and startling (115 dB) cues. Electromyography (EMG) was recorded from bilateral anterior deltoid (AD) and erector spinae (ES) during shoulder flexion and from bilateral posterior deltoid (PD) and rectus abdominis (RA) during shoulder extension. EMG onset of all muscles shortened during the startling cue in both age groups, suggesting a non-specific modulation of the reticulospinal tract on prime movers (AD or PD) and non-prime movers (ES or RA). Interestingly, APAs of the ES were accelerated in older participants to a similar degree as in younger participants during the startling cue. Conversely, APAs of the RA were not influenced by the startling cue in older participants. Our results suggest differential effects of ageing on functional contributions of the reticulospinal tract to APAs between back extensors and abdominal muscles.
-
Musculoskeletal case-mix adjustment in a UK primary/community care cohort: Testing musculoskeletal models to make recommendations in this setting.Benchmarking musculoskeletal (MSK) services is limited by the need to adjust for differences in patient characteristics/case-mix. Without this providers and services cannot be usefully compared. This paper investigates the predictive ability of case-mix adjustment models in a primary/community care cohort. Objectives: To investigate the predictive ability of two existing MSK case-mix adjustment models and compare to the predictive ability of an evidence informed and statistically informed model. Method: A secondary analysis of the 'Subgrouping for Targeted Treatment in Musculoskeletal Conditions' cluster randomised controlled trial data (n = 1211). Stepwise linear regression models were built and compared using available baseline variables. The MSK-HQ was used as the primary functional status outcome. Results: Two existing models were compared (UK National PROMs Model, US FOTO Model) using available variables. Of these models the modified US FOTO model showed the best predictive ability in this cohort predicting 44% of the variation in MSK-HQ outcome, the modified UK National PROMs model predicted 41%. A newly developed evidence informed model (Keele Model 1) performed no better than the existing models, and a statistically informed model (Keele Model 2) gave only an additional 2% increase in model power compared to the modified US FOTO model. Conclusion: All models showed strong predictive ability. The modified US FOTO model looks to be best suited to the UK primary/community care cohort of the existing models. This model performed so well that we recommend that this model is used in a UK setting moving forwards rather than development of an alternative UK model.
-
A systematic review of the methods and drugs used for performing suprascapular nerve block injections for the non-surgical management of chronic shoulder painSuprascapular nerve block (SSNB) injections are growing in popularity as a treatment option for people with chronic shoulder pain. The optimal method of injection and aftercare is unknown. This review describes the current methods and drugs used for performing SSNB injections in the non-surgical management of adults with chronic shoulder pain in order to inform future research in this area. Systematic searches of CINAHL, MEDLINE (OVID), AMED, Embase databases and the Cochrane Library were undertaken from inception to June 2020. Data on the method and drugs used for injection and aftercare were extracted and summarised for areas of commonality and discrepancy. We included 53 studies in this review. In total, eight different injection methods were reported within the included studies. Indirect surface land-marked methods were the most common method reported in 21 studies. Direct surface land-marked methods were reported in 12 studies. Ultrasound-guided methods used alone were reported in 16 studies. Both fluoroscopy and computed tomography methods used alone were reported in one study each. Electromyography was used in combination with other injection methods in nine studies. Wide variation in the composition of the injectate was observed between studies. Local anaesthetic was used within injectate preparations in all studies. Local anaesthetic used alone was reported in 20 studies, combined with steroid in 29 studies and combined with various other components in 5 studies. Physiotherapy following injection was reported in 26 studies. Reported details of physiotherapy varied considerably. This review identified substantial variation in the methods and drugs used to perform SSNB injection in clinical trials. Current literature demonstrates a wide range of methods used for SSNB injection administration. Consensus research defining standardised practice for SSNB injection is now needed to guide future clinical practice and research.
-
Benchmarking community/primary care musculoskeletal services: A narrative review and recommendation.Introduction: High quality data on service performance is essential in healthcare to evidence efficacy, efficiency, and value. There remains a paucity of publicly reported data in community and primary care musculoskeletal (MSK) services. There is also a lack of guidance on which metrics MSK services should be collecting and reporting, and how this data could be used to directly improve patient outcomes, experiences, and value. Method: A narrative review of the evidence around benchmarking MSK services was undertaken with a focus on how to develop routine data collection within community/primary care settings, and how to develop benchmarking capabilities for the future, looking towards a national MSK audit. This evidence was triangulated with the findings from recent MSK data studies undertaken by the authors and emerging UK policy and guidance in this area. Recommendations: To enable MSK benchmarking services need to collect consistent, standardised outcomes and, therefore, we have developed a recommendation on a minimum MSK 'core outcome set' of Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) and Patient Reported Experience Measures (PREMs) (PROMs: MSK-HQ, NPRS, WPAI; PREMs: National MSK PREM). In addition, we make recommendations on the use of a standardised evidence-based method for case-mix adjustment and outlier identification (using the following baseline demographics and clinical factors; age, sex, ethnicity, pain site, comorbidities, duration of symptoms, previous surgery, previous pain episodes), alongside considerations on how this data should be integrated and reported within NHS systems. Conclusions: Capturing high quality MSK data in a standardised, consistent, and sustainable way is a significant challenge. Policy holders, commissioners, managers, and clinicians need to be realistic with expectations, and take time to explore barriers to implementation including, funding, digital infrastructure/intra-operability, data sharing/governance, digital literacy, and local/national leadership. Next steps include developing a national MSK audit programme to provide a benchmarking model to support continuous improvements in care quality for patients living with MSK conditions.
-
Benchmarking quality of care using patient reported outcome measure data for patients presenting with musculoskeletal conditions in primary care GP practicesBackground: Patient Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs) evaluate health status from a patient perspective. They can be used to support care at a patient level but also collectively to review quality of care across care providers. Vast amounts of patients with musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions present to General Practice (GP) primary care practitioners each year. Variation in patient outcomes in this setting however has not been reported. Objective: To identify variation in patient outcomes measured using the musculoskeletal health questionnaire (MSK-HQ) PROM for adults presenting to 20 GP practices in the UK with MSK conditions. Methods: A secondary analysis of the STarT MSK cluster randomised controlled trial dataset. A standardised case-mix adjustment model, adjusting for condition complexity co-variates, was used to calculate predicted 6-month follow-up MSK-HQ scores, and used to compare adjusted and un-adjusted health gain (n = 868). Patient MSK-HQ change outcomes were aggregated to practice level and boxplots used to display outlier GP practices for un-adjusted and adjusted outcomes. Results: Substantial variation in patient outcomes was seen across the 20 practices, even after case-mix adjustment, with mean change in MSK-HQ scores ranging from 6 to 12 points. Boxplots displaying un-adjusted outcomes showed one negative GP practice outlier and two positive outliers. However, the boxplots displaying case-mix adjusted outcomes showed no negative outliers, with two practices remaining as positive outliers, and one practice additionally becoming a positive outlier. Conclusion: This study showed a two-fold GP practice variation in patient outcomes measured using the MSK-HQ PROM. To our knowledge it is the first study to demonstrate that (a) a standardised case-mix adjustment method can be used to fairly compare patient health outcome variation in GP care, and (b) that case-mix adjustment changes benchmarking findings with regards to provider performance and outlier identification. This has important implications for identifying best practice exemplars and thereby helping to improve the quality of MSK primary care in the future.